5 successful ecommerce referral programs and why they work

Imagine you’re catching up with a friend about your latest online shopping adventures, and out of nowhere, you find yourself smitten with a brand you’d never heard of before. Sound familiar? You’re definitely not alone. 

In fact, over 80 percent of consumers stumble upon new brands through casual conversations, and most trust these word-of-mouth recommendations more than traditional advertisements. That’s the magic of a genuine referral.

Successful referral programs are simple, clear, and easy to use. They include eye-catching visuals, clear CTAs, and straightforward rules. The best ones even throw in leaderboards and reward exchanges to keep things fun and competitive. But how do you create a referral program that your customers will love and use? Let’s dive into what makes a referral program great.

Why is ecommerce referral marketing a great way to build brand awareness and revenue?

Referral marketing works because people trust recommendations from friends and family more than ads. Around 86 percent of consumers say recommendations and reviews are important in their purchase decisions, while only two percent consider traditional ads important in their purchase decisions. 

Customers trust the opinions of people they know – 88 percent of people trust recommendations from friends and family.

Plus, with so many product options, consumers want a voice they trust to give them guidance. That’s why nearly nine in ten shoppers say recommendations are important in their buying decisions. 

When customers love your products, they’re likely to share them with their network—and with the right incentives, even more so. 

Here’s why ecommerce referral programs are a win-win for your brand:

• Amplified reach: Each referral extends your brand’s reach, bringing in new customers who might not have discovered you otherwise.
• Cost-effective growth: It’s much cheaper than running ads or launching big campaigns—your current customers do the heavy lifting.
• Higher conversion rates: Referred customers are more likely to convert because they come with built-in trust.
• Customer loyalty: Offering rewards strengthens the relationship with your existing customers, turning them into repeat buyers.

5 ecommerce stores with well-structured referral programs 

Building a referral marketing program can drive impressive results. By incentivizing customers and making it simple for them to recommend your store, you can create loyal brand advocates and drive new business your way. 

But it’s not always easy to know how to structure your referral program for the best results. To help you build a referral program structure that fits your business, here are five stores hitting the mark. 

1. Homage offers an interactive gaming experience

While product quality is the main consideration in determining whether a referrer will remain loyal to a brand after recommending a product, 42 percent of consumers say recognition of whether loyal customers are rewarded influences their loyalty. 

Clothing brand Homage makes its referral program stand out by gamifying the experience and consistently rewarding customers for their loyalty. Through a leaderboard structure, customers earn points they can exchange for rewards, creating a sense of competition and engagement. Customers can pick the rewards they want, which keeps them motivated to refer more friends.

Homage also integrated its affiliate and influencer programs, expanding the reach of the referral strategy. By offering both gamified rewards and influencer partnerships, Homage keeps customers excited while growing their audience through social networks.

See how Homage boosts revenue by 485 percent with an integrated affiliate, referral and influencer program.

2. PayPayl entices customers with cashback for referrals

PayPal’s referral program makes it easy for customers to earn cashback by simply referring friends. PayPal’s program works well because it taps into what most consumers want—cash. 

In fact, our research shows that 58 percent of people prefer cash over other reward types, making PayPal’s offer highly appealing to advocates.

Existing customers can earn up to $100 by referring ten friends. 

To make the process even smoother, PayPal includes a clear FAQs section on their referral page. Customers can quickly see how to maximize their referrals and how the cashback system works, ensuring users feel confident and informed when participating.

3. YoloFoods has easy-to-understand language and visuals

YoloFoods nails simplicity with a referral program that’s easy for anyone to follow. The language on their referral page is clear, removing any confusion about how to refer friends or earn rewards. On top of that, the brand uses eye-catching visuals that make each step even easier to understand.

The program offers multiple ways for customers to earn points, which can be redeemed for discount vouchers. Customers can earn points by referring friends, following the brand on Instagram, or sharing a post on Facebook. YoloFoods also gives shoppers points on their birthday. 

This flexibility motivates customers to participate. YoloFoods also has a robust affiliate program managed on impact.com. By automating partner management, YoloFoods expands its reach and gives more motivation to participate. YoloFoods also has a robust affiliate program that’s managed on impact.com. By automating their partner management, YoloFoods expands its reach, while making the process simple for both customers and partners. Plus, they’ve achieved seven times their affiliate revenue.  

4. Casper offers third-party gift cards—it makes business sense

Casper’s referral program is effective because it’s simple and offers clear rewards for both the referrer and the person being referred. Instead of offering discounts on future purchases, Casper rewards referrers with Amazon gift cards. This makes perfect sense since most customers won’t need another bed for 10 years. The gift card option is far more practical and attractive, giving referrers a tangible benefit they can use immediately.

On top of that, it’s a double-sided program, meaning both the referrer and the person they refer receive rewards, which is a proven method for boosting participation. Our research found that 78 percent of brands now use double-sided programs, and 65 percent of referrers prefer when both parties benefit. Casper’s approach taps into this preference, making the program even more appealing to its customers.

5. Good AirX gives new and existing customers a percentage discount to drive purchases

Good AirX designed its referral program to encourage both new and existing customers to make purchases. By offering a percentage discount to both the referrer and the person they refer—but giving a slightly larger discount to the referrer — it motivates customers to actively spread the word. Advocates receive a fair reward while driving sales for the business.

Both parties must make a purchase to unlock the discount, which ensures that the program consistently drives traffic to the store. Plus, the program’s ease of use allows customers to create personalized referral links they can share across any platform, making it easy to spread the word.

Pitfalls to avoid when creating an ecommerce referral program

Now that you know what makes a referral program successful, let’s look at some common mistakes that could get in your way. 

Hiding your referral program

One of the biggest mistakes brands make is hiding their referral program, where customers can’t easily find it. If your program isn’t front and center, it might as well not exist. 

Make sure it’s visible across your website—on product pages, in your email campaigns, and even at checkout. The more places customers see it, the more likely they are to participate and share. A well-promoted referral program gets attention, while a hidden one gets overlooked.

Offering low or irrelevant rewards

If the reward doesn’t excite your customers, they won’t be motivated to refer anyone. Offering low-value or irrelevant rewards is a quick way to derail your referral program. Make sure the incentives are enticing and aligned with what your customers actually want—whether discounts, free products, or exclusive perks. The better the reward, the more likely customers will be to spread the word and engage with your program.

Displaying widgets that are difficult to find and navigate

If your referral widgets are buried deep in your site or hard to use, customers will lose interest fast. Complex or hidden referral forms create friction, discouraging even your most loyal fans from participating. Make sure your widgets are easy to find, simple to navigate, and mobile-friendly. The smoother the process, the more likely people are to refer friends and family without getting frustrated.

Not continually adjusting the program to match changing customer needs

Customer preferences change over time, and your referral program needs to keep up. If you don’t regularly review and tweak your program, you risk losing engagement. Whether updating the rewards, refreshing the referral messaging, or making the process more user-friendly, staying in tune with your customers’ evolving needs is key to maintaining interest and maximizing results.

Checklist for creating a good ecommerce referral program

What makes a referral program truly successful? Let’s break down the key points from the examples above:

• Keep it simple: A clear, easy-to-understand program encourages more participation. Customers don’t want to navigate complicated rules to refer their friends.
• Use eye-catching visuals: Make sure your referral page grabs attention with bold, engaging visuals that guide customers through the process.
• Offer relevant rewards: High enough rewards that matter to your customers, like cashback or discounts, are essential to motivating them to refer others.
• Clear CTAs: Strong, actionable calls to action ensure customers know exactly what to do next.
• Multiple earning opportunities: Whether through points, cash, or other incentives, offering various ways to earn makes your program flexible.
• Get customer feedback: Regularly asking for feedback ensures that you’re meeting customer expectations and can improve your program over time.

Customer feedback is especially crucial. It allows you to adapt the program to changing preferences and catch any roadblocks that may deter people from participating. Plus, some rewards work better than others. 

For instance, research shows that giving a reward tied to the brand (e.g., a percent discount, points, or gift cards) drives more referrals than giving a cash payout. However, sometimes using a third-party reward makes more sense. 

Make referral programs part of your marketing playbook

Referral programs are a powerful tool for ecommerce brands looking to boost both revenue and brand awareness. By tapping into the trust that customers have in personal recommendations, you can drive new traffic and encourage repeat purchases. 

As seen in the examples above, the most successful referral programs are simple, offer relevant rewards, and continuously evolve based on customer feedback. When executed well, a referral program not only attracts new customers but also fosters loyalty, creating a win-win situation for both your brand and its advocates.

FAQs